Treaties: When are they part of “the supreme law of the land”?

Posted By | October 17, 2016 6:36 am

Language of Liberty, by Publius Huldah

If the U.S. Senate ratifies the U.N. Convention on the Rights of the Child, will it become part of the supreme Law of the Land?   If the Senate ratifies the “cap and trade” climate change treaty, or U.N. Arms Trade Treaty, will that become part of the supreme Law of the Land?

We hear it said that whenever the Senate ratifies a treaty, it becomes part of “the supreme Law of the Land”. But is that True? Not necessarily! Walk with me, and I will show you how to think through this question, and how to analyze other constitutional questions which come your way.

You must always ask: Is this authorized in the Constitution? Where exactly in the Constitution? And precisely what is authorized by the Constitution?

  1. Does the federal government have authority to make treaties? Can treaties be about any object? Or, are the proper objects of treaties limited by The Constitution?

Article II, §2, cl. 2, U.S. Constitution, says the President:”… shall have Power, by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate, to make Treaties, provided two-thirds of the Senators present concur…” Article VI, cl. 2 says: ”This Constitution, and the Laws of the United States which shall be made in Pursuance thereof; and all Treaties made, or which shall be made, under the Authority of the United States, shall be the supreme Law of the Land; and the judges in every State shall be bound thereby, any Thing in the Constitution or Laws of any State to the Contrary notwithstanding.”

Thus, we see that the federal government is authorized to make treaties. Now, we must find out whether there are limitations on this treaty making power.

  1. It is a classic rule of construction (rules for understanding the objective meaning of texts) 1 that one must give effect to every word and phrase. The clause does not say, “Treaties made by the United States are part of the supreme Law of the Land”. Instead, it says Treaties made under the Authority of the United States, are part of the supreme Law of the Land.

So we see right away that a Treaty is part of the supreme Law of the Land only if it is made “under the Authority of the United States”.

  1. From where do the President and the Senate get Authority to act? From The Constitution. The objects of their lawful powers are enumerated in the Constitution. Thus, the President and Senate must be authorized in the Constitution to act on an object before any Treaty made by them on that object qualifies as part of “the supreme Law of the Land”. If the Constitution does not authorize the President and Congress to act on an object, the Treaty is not “Law” – it is a mere usurpation, and deserves to be treated as such. (Federalist Paper No. 33, last para).

Because the Constitution is “fundamental” law (Federalist No. 78, 11th & 12th paras), it is The Standard by which the legitimacy of all Presidential Acts, all Acts of Congress, all Treaties, and all Judicial Decisions is measured (Federalist No. 78, 10th para).

  1. In Federalist No. 44 (7th para from end), James Madison explains why it is necessary that Art. VI, cl. 2, provide that federal treaties have supremacy over State Constitutions. Otherwise, a treaty which violates a State Constitution would have no effect in that State:

“…as the constitutions of the States differ much from each other, it might happen that a treaty or national law of great and equal importance to the States would interfere with some and not with other constitutions and would consequently be valid in some of the States at the same time that it would have no effect in others.” Madison thus illustrates the Principle that a treaty which interferes with the Constitution has no effect. I found no other discussion in The Federalist Papers on this point.

So, let us turn to Thomas Jefferson, who wrote: 2 “In giving to the President and Senate a power to make treaties, the Constitution meant only to authorize them to carry into effect, by way of treaty, any powers they might constitutionally exercise.” –Thomas Jefferson: The Anas, 1793. ME 1:408

“Surely the President and Senate cannot do by treaty what the whole government is interdicted from doing in any way.” –Thomas Jefferson: Parliamentary Manual, 1800. ME 2:442

“According to the rule established by usage and common sense, of construing one part of the instrument by another, the objects on which the President and Senate may exclusively act by treaty are much reduced, but the field on which they may act with the sanction of the Legislature is large enough; and I see no harm in rendering their sanction necessary, and not much harm in annihilating the whole treaty-making power, except as to making peace.” –Thomas Jefferson to James Madison, 1796. ME 9:330

  1. So! The treaty making power of the United States is very limited. What, then, are the proper objects of treaties? To find the answer, we must go to The Constitution to see what it authorizes the President and the Congress to do. The Constitution delegates to Congress powers “To regulate Commerce with foreign Nations … and with the Indian Tribes” (Art I, § 8, cl. 3); and “To declare War…and make Rules concerning Captures on Land and Water” (Art I, § 8, cl. 11). The Constitution authorizes the President to “…appoint Ambassadors, other public Ministers and Consuls…” (Art II, §2, cl. 2).

The authors of The Federalist Papers address the treaty making power of the United States. John Jay says treaties relate to “war, peace, and to commerce” and to the promotion of “trade and navigation” (Federalist No. 64, 3rd & 6th paras). Madison says treaties also relate to sending and receiving ambassadors & consuls and to commerce (Federalist No. 42, 1st four paras).

There may be additional objects of the treaty making power authorized in The Constitution. For example, Art I, § 8, cl. 8, authorizes Congress “To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries“. Thus, The United States could properly enter into treaties respecting patents & copyrights. 3

  1. Let’s look now at the proposed U.N. Convention on the Rights of the Child. If ratified by the Senate, would it become part of “the supreme Law of the Land”? To answer that Question, we must ask: Does the Constitution grant to Congress the power to make laws respecting “children”? Does the Constitution grant to the Executive Branch jurisdiction over “children”?

The answer to both questions is “NO!” In addition, the 10th Amendment says if a power is not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, or prohibited to the States by Art. I, §10, it is reserved to the States or the people. Thus, jurisdiction over “children” is reserved to the States or the People! Accordingly, if the Senate were to ratify the U.N. Convention on the Rights of the Child, the treaty would NOT become part of “the supreme Law of the Land”, because it would not have been made under the Authority of the United States. It would be a mere usurpation and would deserve to be treated as such.

If the Senate were to ratify the cap-and-trade “climate” treaty, which, among other things, would force energy companies to buy allowances or permits for their “carbon emissions”, would it become part of “the supreme law of the Land”? Or the U.N. Arms Trade treaty, which provides for civilian disarmament by U.N. forces? You are now equipped to find the answer, and you can confidently defend it! Do not forget: The federal government may not lawfully circumvent the U.S. Constitution by international treaties. It may NOT do by Treaty what it is not permitted to do by the U.S. Constitution.

  1. Finally, Thomas Jefferson points to a legislative remedy if the President and the Senate ignore the constitutional limits on the treaty making power of the United States. Thomas Jefferson says: 2 “We conceive the constitutional doctrine to be, that though the President and Senate have the general power of making treaties, yet wherever they include in a treaty matters confided by the Constitution to the three [did he mean, “two”?] branches of Legislature, an act of legislation will be requisite to confirm these articles, and that the House of Representatives, as one branch of the Legislature, are perfectly free to pass the act or to refuse it, governing themselves by their own judgment whether it is for the good of their constituents to let the treaty go into effect or not.” –Thomas Jefferson to James Monroe, 1796. ME 9:329

“I was glad… to hear it admitted on all hands, that laws of the United States, subsequent to a treaty, control its operation, and that the Legislature is the only power which can control a treaty. Both points are sound beyond doubt.”–Thomas Jefferson to James Madison, 1798. ME 10:41

What a man! And our system of checks & balances is an elegant one, indeed!

  1. Folks! For too long, we have blindly accepted whatever we hear others say. Someone on TV says, “If the Senate ratifies this treaty, it will become part of the supreme Law of the Land!” And not only do we believe it, we repeat it to others. And thus, we became part of the misinformation dissemination network. In order to restore our Constitutional Republic with its federal form of government, we must rediscover how to think and analyze. And then, we must boldly say, “They don’t have authority under The Constitution to do that!”

Publius Huldah is an author, speaker, lawyer and strict constructionist of The U.S. Constitution. Read footnotes and more at publiushuldah.com.

The Language of Liberty series is a collaborative effort of the Center for Self Governance (CSG) Administrative Team. The authors include administrative staff, selected students, and guest columnists. The views expressed by the authors are their own and do not reflect the views of CSG. They may be contacted at info@tncsg.org To learn more, go to CenterForSelfGovernance.com.

No comments yet.


The comments are closed.

© Copyright 2020 | Sparta Live

vape: vape shops columbus ohio smok rolo badge vs suorin drop vape pen with box mod best portable vape for dry herb ecig kanger aspire plato ecig one smok xpro m80 plus review does ecig juice go bad nord smok coils vape juice 3 nicotine enjoy pods e cigarette china pre built coils vape how to prevent vaping in school ecig labor day sale 2015 x cube smok one vape pen with cartridge wismec theorem vape shows 2015 pink box mod for sale smok nord 15w ultra portable pod kit beginner vapes stix vape battery joyetech notch coil review island voopoo drag 2 unregulated box mod kit dry herb vaporizer amazon mesh vape tanks best vape mod 2014 aspire temp control coil ecig puts out to much vapor baby beast tank stuck what is rdta vape golden juul vape setups the factory vape electronic cigarettes buy crown uwell ecig statistics voopoo uforce replacement coils direct vapor coupon code 2017 voopoo u force t2 freemax fireluke mesh coils ijust kit voopoo drag change from f to c nkd salt nic vape juice voopoo drag 2 doors ecig shops in new hope voopoo uforce cover thc vape juice for sale online

male enhancement: how can i raise my libido titan male enhancement pill most common medicine dangerous power g5 review trestolone pills endorsed by ed oneill how to drive around and find sex ed pills sold at walgreens standard penis sizes fildena super active which doctor to consult for erectile dysfunction how old are you when your penis stops growing how long after taking viagra can you eat can i buy viagra at cvs viagra bay area male breast enhancement surgery testo boost x v9 male sexual stimulant best enhancement pills jet pro x male enhancement pills are penis enlargement pills real natural penis growth exercise can stress effect sex drive how to get my pennis thicker txts to drive a man wild after sex ylang ylang essential oil penis growth yeni akit viagra best male enhancement pills 2017 in india different types of viagra pills what is the best and safest way to increase penis size x vrs viagra penis growth pills fact or fiction how to convince doctor viagra erect males blue cross blue shield federal prescription drug list what arouses a man how to cut 100mg viagra why viagra didnt work how to purchase generic viagra viagra patent deutschland when does viagra cialis its peak ram juice male enhancement what happens when a teenager takes viagra hormone cream for penis enlargement how to take viagra sildenafil how can one increase penis size vende walmat las pidoras vigrx plus do opiates increase penis size my boyfriend has low libido penis enlargement real penis video diary cant masturbate due to low libido will xanogen male enhancement dietary supplement cause a false positive of thc

weight loss: best weight loss medication keto diet crab stuffed mushroom recipes prescription meds to lose weight what is the best fast working diet pills to lose weight what depression medication causes weight loss can crossfit help you lose weight do opiates raise blood pressure keto diet recipes for vegetarians indian garcinia cambogia walmart gummies the fastest way to lose weight on your stomach prescription appetite suppressant side effects how to lose weight when breastfeeding rhodiola weight loss does drinking apple cider vinegar help you lose weight hca in diet pills matcha recipes keto can you bring diet pills on a plane what is the fastest way to lose weight and gain muscle best ratio diet pills ranch packet recipes keto gnc fat loss what takes only a few minutes a day to lose weight on world new tonight founder keto recipes how much weight can i lose on a 24 hour fast best keto bread recipes 2018 eat the same thing every day to lose weight keto instant pot recipes pinterest prescription appetite suppressants list rotisserie chicken casserole recipes keto keto burn diet pills 1200 mg ketosis mama june weight lose natural fat blocker coffee to help lose weight riduzone appetite suppressant is there a pill to help me lose weight how much weight can you lose wearing a sauna suit easiest way to lose weight reddit best keyto diet pills how long will it take me to lose 40lbs on weight watchers pill with r on it how did chlo thvenin lose weight raspberry ketone slim reviews lose weight stretegy what to eat with grapefruit to lose weight how does winni make you lose weight shredz ab workout why did my ex lose weight after we broke up should i eat rice if im tryimg to lose weight lose 8 pounds in 4 weeks diet pills phetamol

exam: Examcollection 9A0-031 Dumps Is What You Need To Take, Experts Revised CAT-140 Exam Cram On Sale, Useful HP0-J60 Certification with PDF and VCE Engine, 100% Success Rate HC-223-CHS Exam Practice Pdf Are The Best Materials, To Pass Your Exam HC-011-812-ENU Exam Test Are Based On The Real Exam, Discount HC-035-550-ENU Questions For Sale, Sale Latest 000-084 Test Pdf Online Store, Money Back Guarantee 000-861 Brain Dumps Will Be More Popular, Latest Release 000-907 Certification Material Are Based On The Real Exam, Provide Latest C2150-596 Self Study Online, The Most Effective HP2-N41 Certification Are The Best Materials, Sale Best HP2-N40 Exam Test Are The Best Materials, Testking A2010-650 Exam Paper On Sale, Certshared C2180-183 Certification Exam UP To 50% Off, Examcollection 000-604 Exam Paper Pdf With Accurate Answers, Buy Best 000-M43 Certificate Will Be More Popular, Real 000-SS1 Exam Online, Testking 000-817 Exam Dumps Pdf Online Store, Provide Latest 070-178 Vce Are The Best Materials, Buy 070-528 New Questions On Sale, Reliable and Professional 1Z1-046 Actual Exam For Each Candidate, Provides 1Z0-583 Certification Material 100% Pass With A High Score, Easily To Pass 1Z0-223 Exam Collection UP To 50% Off, Valid and updated 050-V40-ENVCSE02 Practice Test Pdf Online Shop, New Release VCS-352 Exam Questions Online,

face mask: fashionable face masks cvs mask black face mask costume bicycle helmet bubble face shield face mask for wrinkles and loose skin avocado and oatmeal face mask what is the max pressure rating of a dreamwear full face mask n95 respirator medical clearance alina takes a shit on the face of a masked man respirator positive half mask family that 4 brothers died when taken off respirator how to reset n95 e box to factory setting how long does r95 respirator mean amazon 6311 respirator respirator cartridge for mold wma headgear with face shield adult medium do i have to shave my beard for respirator fitting flat fold n95 particulate respirator dynarex corporation 3m n95 respirator fit testing video what kind of respirator for oxalic acid p95 vs n95 wildfire is coronavirus common in florifa face masks to prevent bed bug bites how often do you use face masks peel off why do crystal from black ink have a mask on my face trouble respirator mask news cut off wheel dust mask low profile dust mask jm solution anti dust therapy mask diy dust mask bra construction dust mask grinning face what are the importance of respirator fit testing osha dust mask termites 3m dust mask for woodworking rite aid stock ceramic dust mask rite aid florida particulate respirator n95 uses what is the icd 10 code for coronavirus what dies a face mask do most severe coronavirus face masks natural coronavirus online mold respirator home depot power face shield respirators full face diving mask for sale silver face mask with light green eye shield safety green rz dust mask conquer helmet face shield sa co face shield reviews

cbd oil: hemp seed oil cystic acne marijuana dizziness the best cbd oil louisville ky how to take cbd isolate cbd patch for pain cheap cbd vape talyoni cbd oil can cbd oil help a cold chinese marijuana isolate vs full spectrum cbd is cbd oil legal in utah 2019 ringos gift cbd flower cbd oil in connecticut will cbd vape oil show up on a drug test cbd oil and infertility massage warehouse cbd oil cbd and concussion charlottes web cbd pills where can i buy pure cbd oil near me effect of cbd where to buy cbd in oahu cbd oils for pain cbd in england cbd oil san diego kratom vs cbd oil cannabis oil company reference dose definition cbd oil delivery buy extract can cannabis oil cure copd life is good dragonfly benefits of pure potent cbd oil elevated plus maze mouse cannabis oil capsules for sale nlm urban dictionary how much cbd isolate can be dissolved into coconut oil to make out definition cbd oil and calcium channel blockers ron jeremy male enhancement my complete cbd cbd oil checked luggage cbd oil for social anxiety reddit does the va prescribe cbd oil sydney cbd restaurants open sunday dinner can cbd oil make you itchy cbd oil wisconsin for sale latest news on hemp oil cbd long range order has synthetic cbd oil caused any deaths arthritis definition in spanish